Duty to consult saves four mature trees in Wellingborough

Harrowden rd trees street pic no.2 29 12 25

North Northamptonshire Council has abandoned its proposal to fell four mature trees on Harrowden Road in Wellingborough, after the campaign group Wellingborough Walks Action Group (WWAG), challenged both the process and the evidence base.

The trees, which have been under threat of felling for over a year, were initially earmarked for removal after insurers of a nearby property stated that the trees needed to be removed to address subsidence issues.

WWAG relied on section 96A of the Highways Act 1980 and government guidance to highlight inadequacies in the consultation process. Section 96A, introduced by section 115 of the Environment Act 2021, requires local highway authorities in England to consult the public before felling qualifying street trees. Government guidance explains the process that should be followed, including what information needs to be provided to the public.

WWAG’s representations resulted in a new consultation process. Expert reports commissioned by WWAG from a structural engineer and arboriculturalist highlighted the flaws in the Council’s and insurer’s evidence.

WWAG’s submissions prompted the Council to obtain its own independent reports. They agreed with WWAG’s findings, and concluded that removing the trees “would not solve the problem” and recommended underpinning or rebuilding the porch instead. Based on the new evidence, the Council resolved to retain the trees.

The case serves as a positive example of how the duty to consult can improve the quality of decision making and save valuable street trees.

Alice Goodenough of Goodenough Ring Solicitors acted for WWAG.